Black Lion pub appeals Bord Pleanála decision to refuse plans

THE Black Lion Public House in Clondalkin village has lodged an appeal with An Bord Pleanála after it was refused permission and refused retention for a single-storey pavilion structure.

Applicant Greenwin Ltd lodged the appeal against South Dublin County Council’s decision for the development which consisted of the retention of a single-storey pavilion structure, floor area 203 sq m, and will consist of two proposed acoustic lobbies, a floor area of 11.6 sq m, at the rear of the existing premises.

It is noted in the application that the pavilion structure was introduced initially in response to Covid-19 HSE restrictions, to facilitate the required levels of social distancing for patrons.

“This illness remains a concern for many and so [the pavilion] is still very popular with our patrons,” stated the applicant.

“Although not planned, the pavilion structure is predominantly occupied by the younger patrons, thereby giving our older patrons more space and a more relaxed setting within the original public house itself.

“Reflecting this natural separation of our patrons and the organic development of two separate areas, with the pavilion enjoyed by our younger patrons.

“We have also used it during daytime at the weekend for televised sporting events that are also shown in the main pub.

“The pavilion is not used for events other than the type of activities which already occur or have previously occurred within the main premises in the past.”

Seven third-party submissions were lodged on the application, where concerns about noise levels, proximity to residential properties, and a “significant impact on the quality of life” of surrounding residents were raised.

On August 6, South Dublin County Council decided to refuse retention permission for the pavilion, and to refuse planning permission for a proposal for two acoustic lobbies in it.

The local authority stated it would contravene the objectives of the County Development Plan, which seeks to enhance and preserve the historic character of Architectural Conservation Areas like Clondalkin village.

“The proposal, if permitted, would set an undesirable precedent for other similar developments,” stated the council.

“[These] would in themselves and cumulatively, be harmful to the special character of the protected structure or the special character of the ACA and amenities of the surrounding area and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.”